Should I Use Brick or Vinyl Siding?
Should I Use Brick or Vinyl Siding? A Complete Guide for New Home Builds Building a custom home is one of life’s most exciting adventures. Every decision matters, from the foundation to the roof. But perhaps no choice is more visible or impactful than your exterior material. When you ask yourself, “Should I use brick […]
Jason BarnettBuilding a custom home is one of life’s most exciting adventures. Every decision matters, from the foundation to the roof. But perhaps no choice is more visible or impactful than your exterior material. When you ask yourself, “Should I use brick or vinyl siding?” you’re making a decision that will affect your home’s appearance, value, and maintenance for decades to come.
Make sure and visit with us on our Facebook Page. Thanks for being a part of what makes My Plan Store amazing!
This comprehensive guide will walk you through everything you need to know about both brick and vinyl siding. By the end, you’ll have the confidence to make the right choice for your dream home.
When planning your custom home, the exterior material sets the tone for your entire property. The question “Should I use brick or vinyl siding?” comes up in nearly every home design consultation. Both materials offer unique benefits that can enhance your home’s appeal and functionality.
Brick has been a trusted building material for thousands of years. Its timeless appeal and incredible durability make it a favorite among homeowners who want a classic, sophisticated look. Vinyl siding, on the other hand, offers modern convenience with excellent versatility and cost-effectiveness.
Your choice between these materials will impact several important factors: your initial construction budget, long-term maintenance costs, energy efficiency, and overall home value. Understanding these differences is crucial when you’re trying to decide between brick and vinyl siding for your new construction project.
Brick construction involves individual clay units that are fired in kilns and then laid with mortar. This creates a solid, durable wall system that can last for centuries. When homeowners wonder “Should I use brick or vinyl siding?” they often think first about brick’s reputation for longevity.
Traditional brick offers incredible strength and fire resistance. It naturally regulates temperature, helping keep your home cool in summer and warm in winter. The material comes in various colors, textures, and sizes, allowing for creative design possibilities that can make your custom home truly unique.
Modern brick installation techniques have evolved to include cavity wall systems, where brick serves as an exterior veneer over a structural wall. This approach combines brick’s aesthetic appeal with improved insulation properties.
Vinyl siding consists of PVC (polyvinyl chloride) panels that interlock to create a weather-resistant exterior. Since its introduction in the 1950s, vinyl siding has become increasingly popular due to its affordability and low maintenance requirements.
Today’s vinyl siding bears little resemblance to early versions. Modern manufacturing techniques create products that closely mimic wood, stone, and even brick textures. High-quality vinyl siding resists fading, cracking, and warping while providing excellent weather protection.
The installation process for vinyl siding is typically faster than brick, which can help reduce construction timelines for your custom home project.
Budget considerations often drive the initial question of “Should I use brick or vinyl siding?” The upfront costs differ significantly between these materials, but the long-term financial picture tells a more complex story.
Vinyl siding typically costs between $3 to $12 per square foot installed, depending on quality and style. Premium vinyl options with enhanced durability and realistic textures fall on the higher end of this range.
Brick installation generally ranges from $8 to $25 per square foot, making it significantly more expensive initially. The wide price range reflects differences in brick quality, regional labor costs, and installation complexity.
For a typical 2,000 square foot home exterior, vinyl siding might cost $6,000 to $24,000, while brick could range from $16,000 to $50,000. These numbers help explain why many homeowners initially lean toward vinyl when asking “Should I use brick or vinyl siding?”
While brick costs more upfront, it often provides better long-term value. Brick homes typically see higher resale values and better market appeal. Real estate studies show that brick homes often sell for 5-10% more than comparable homes with other siding materials.
Vinyl siding may require replacement every 20-30 years, while quality brick can last 100+ years with minimal maintenance. When calculating lifetime costs, this durability difference becomes significant.
The question “Should I use brick or vinyl siding?” often comes down to how much maintenance you want to handle over the years.
Brick requires minimal ongoing maintenance, which makes it attractive for busy homeowners. The primary maintenance tasks include:
Most brick maintenance is preventive rather than urgent. The material’s natural durability means unexpected repairs are rare.
Vinyl siding requires more regular attention but simpler maintenance tasks:
While individual maintenance tasks are easier with vinyl, they occur more frequently than with brick.
Regional climate plays a crucial role when deciding “Should I use brick or vinyl siding?” Each material performs differently under various weather conditions.
Brick excels in most climate conditions. Its thermal mass helps regulate indoor temperatures, reducing energy costs. In hot climates, brick stays cooler during the day and releases heat slowly at night. In cold regions, quality brick installation with proper insulation provides excellent performance.
However, brick can be vulnerable to freeze-thaw cycles in areas with frequent temperature fluctuations around freezing. Proper installation and quality materials minimize these concerns.
Modern vinyl siding handles most weather conditions well. It won’t rot, rust, or corrode like some other materials. However, extreme temperature variations can cause expansion and contraction, potentially leading to gaps or buckling if not properly installed.
High-quality vinyl siding includes UV inhibitors to prevent fading and brittleness from sun exposure. In areas with frequent severe weather, impact-resistant vinyl options provide additional protection.
Energy efficiency has become a major factor in exterior material selection. When homeowners ask “Should I use brick or vinyl siding?” energy performance often influences their decision.
Brick’s thermal mass properties provide natural energy benefits. The material absorbs heat during the day and releases it slowly, helping moderate indoor temperatures. This thermal lag effect can reduce heating and cooling costs, especially in climates with significant day-night temperature variations.
Modern brick installation often includes insulation systems that enhance energy performance while maintaining brick’s aesthetic appeal. Insulated brick veneer systems can achieve excellent R-values while providing all of brick’s traditional benefits.
Vinyl siding itself provides minimal insulation value, but it creates an excellent base for insulation systems. Insulated vinyl siding includes foam backing that improves thermal performance significantly.
The key to energy efficiency with vinyl siding lies in the overall wall system design. Proper insulation, air sealing, and moisture management create high-performance walls that can exceed many brick installations in energy efficiency.
Visual appeal often drives the initial interest in either material. The question “Should I use brick or vinyl siding?” frequently starts with aesthetic preferences.
Brick offers timeless elegance that appeals to many architectural styles. From traditional colonial homes to modern contemporary designs, brick adapts to various aesthetic visions. The material comes in numerous colors, textures, and sizes, allowing for creative patterns and accents.
Brick pairs beautifully with other materials like stone, wood, and metal, creating dynamic exterior designs. The ability to create custom patterns, arches, and decorative elements makes brick particularly appealing for unique custom homes.
Modern vinyl siding has overcome early limitations in appearance. Today’s products mimic wood grain, cedar shakes, and even stone textures with remarkable realism. Color options are virtually unlimited, and many manufacturers offer custom color matching.
Vinyl siding installation allows for creative combinations of textures and colors. Accent panels, decorative trim, and architectural details can create sophisticated looks that rival traditional materials.
Construction timelines matter in custom home building. The choice between materials can significantly impact your move-in date.
Brick installation requires skilled masons and weather-appropriate conditions. The process involves:
Brick installation typically takes longer than vinyl, especially for complex designs or adverse weather conditions.
Vinyl siding installation is generally faster and less weather-dependent:
For homeowners with tight construction timelines, vinyl siding often provides advantages.
Local factors significantly influence material choice. Understanding regional preferences and requirements helps answer “Should I use brick or vinyl siding?” for your specific location.
Some areas have strong preferences for certain materials. The Southeast often favors brick for its traditional appeal and climate performance. Northern regions might prefer vinyl for its resistance to freeze-thaw cycles and easier maintenance.
Local building codes may also influence material choice. Some areas have restrictions or requirements that favor one material over another.
Your local contractor base affects both material choice and project costs. Areas with many skilled masons might offer competitive brick installation pricing. Regions with limited masonry expertise might see higher brick costs and longer timelines.
Research local contractors early in your planning process to understand pricing and availability for both materials.
Sustainability concerns increasingly influence building material decisions. Both brick and vinyl siding have environmental considerations worth evaluating.
Brick production requires significant energy for firing clay, but the material’s longevity offsets this initial impact. Brick buildings often last centuries, making the lifetime environmental cost very low per year of service.
Brick is also recyclable and often reused in new construction projects. The material contains no harmful chemicals and doesn’t off-gas during its service life.
Vinyl siding production uses petroleum-based materials and various chemicals. However, modern manufacturing has improved efficiency and reduced environmental impact.
High-quality vinyl siding can last 30+ years, and many products are recyclable at end of life. The material’s light weight also reduces transportation-related environmental impacts.
After considering all factors, the decision often comes down to personal priorities and circumstances. Here’s how to weigh your options:
Every custom home is unique, making professional guidance valuable when deciding between materials. Experienced builders and designers can help evaluate your specific situation, including:
Site conditions and soil considerations Architectural style compatibility Budget constraints and financing options Local building requirementsPersonal lifestyle factors
The building industry continues evolving, with new technologies affecting both brick and vinyl siding. Understanding future trends helps ensure your choice remains relevant long-term.
Modern brick development focuses on improved insulation integration, recycled content, and enhanced installation methods. New mortar technologies and installation systems are making brick more energy-efficient and faster to install.
Vinyl siding technology continues advancing with better UV resistance, impact protection, and realistic textures. Some manufacturers now offer products with enhanced insulation properties and improved sustainability profiles.
The question “Should I use brick or vinyl siding?” doesn’t have a universal answer, but understanding your priorities makes the choice clearer. Consider your budget, maintenance preferences, aesthetic goals, and long-term plans when making this important decision.
Both materials can create beautiful, functional homes when properly selected and installed. The key is choosing the option that best aligns with your specific needs and circumstances.
Remember that your exterior material choice affects your home’s appearance, performance, and value for decades. Take time to research thoroughly, consult with professionals, and visit homes featuring both materials before making your final decision.
Your custom home represents a significant investment in your family’s future. Whether you choose brick or vinyl siding, make sure your decision supports your long-term goals and provides the performance you need in your specific climate and location.
The choice between brick and vinyl siding ultimately depends on balancing multiple factors: cost, maintenance, aesthetics, durability, and personal preferences. By carefully evaluating each consideration against your specific situation, you’ll make the right choice for your dream home.
Building a custom home involves countless decisions, but few are as visible and long-lasting as your exterior material choice. When you find yourself asking “Should I use brick or vinyl siding?” remember that both materials offer distinct advantages for different situations and priorities.
Brick provides timeless beauty, exceptional durability, and long-term value that appeals to homeowners seeking a classic, low-maintenance solution. Its thermal properties and longevity make it an excellent investment for those who plan to stay in their homes for many years.
Vinyl siding offers modern convenience, design flexibility, and cost-effectiveness that works well for budget-conscious builders and those who appreciate easy maintenance. Today’s vinyl products provide excellent performance and aesthetic appeal that can satisfy most homeowners’ needs.
Your final decision should reflect your personal priorities, local conditions, and long-term goals. Whether you choose the time-tested appeal of brick or the modern advantages of vinyl siding, proper installation and quality materials will ensure your custom home serves your family well for generations to come.
Brick typically lasts 100+ years while quality vinyl siding lasts 20-30 years with proper maintenance.
Brick requires minimal maintenance (repointing every 20-30 years) while vinyl needs annual cleaning and occasional repairs.
Brick costs significantly more upfront ($8-25/sq ft) compared to vinyl siding ($3-12/sq ft installed).
Here’s a little something to make you smile: Why did the contractor choose brick over vinyl siding? Because he wanted to build relationships that would last forever… just like his walls!
Copyright ©